Related
Summary
Someauthors have praise movie and telecasting adaptationsof their books , while others have expressed their dislike of the termination . The book - to - screenland cognitive process is inherently difficult and some elements beloved by volume fan will inevitably be cut . Yet some adaptation are so dissimilar from the source stuff , that it appears that the producers did not care at all about maintaining the book ' magnetic core story and theme .
Failed book version have pass some author to become more Byzantine in the adaptation unconscious process . For model , Rick Riordan became a writer forDisney’sPercy Jackson and the OlympiansTV showafter the disastrous pic adjustment of his books . Other fantasy series that fail as movies have been reboot as TV shows , or are now in exploitation . His Dark Materialswas far more successful thanThe Golden Compass , while anEragonTV seriesis in the deeds . It will be interesting to see if authors like Christopher Paolini will follow Riordan ’s example of becoming call for with unexampled adaptation if they can .
10Stephen King
Disliked: The Shining (1980)
Cast
Stanley Kubrick ’s movie adaptation of Stephen King’sThe Shiningis considered one of thebest repugnance movies of all time . The story follows a family who find themselves be in a haunted hotel in Colorado . Ironically , King has criticizedThe Shiningmoviefor years . He call the movie"a bragging , beautiful Cadillac with no engine inside it"(viaIndieWire ) .
King has also critiqued how multiple characters are depicted . He states ( viaIndieWire),“The character of Jack Torrance has no spark in that movie"and reason that Wendy is"one of the misogynous reference ever put on film”(viaBBC ) . Others agree thatThe Shiningmovie ’s version of Wendyis one of its biggest fault . moreover , King ’s dislike ofThe Shiningis validated by his commendation of other adaptation of his book , includingStand by MeandThe Shawshank Redemption . Martin Luther King Jr. does not generally have a hard time letting go of his stories ; he genuinely believesThe Shiningis a speculative movie .
Stephen King ’s thriller kit and caboodle have offered readers and watcher alike some of the good parachuting panic attack . Here ’s a summing up of the scariest ones adapted to TV
9Michael Ende
Disliked: The NeverEnding Story (1984)
The NeverEnding Story , based on Michael Ende ’s novel of the same name , received modal reviews but gained a rage following . However , Ende pronounce ( viaPeople ) that he was"horrified"by the last product . “I fancy the final script five day before the premiere and only as a result of a discriminative verdict in Munich,“says Ende . “I was horror-stricken . They had exchange the whole sense of the level . Fantastica reappears with no creative force from Bastian . For me this was the centre of the book .
The NeverEnding Story’sdirector Wolfgang Petersen disagreed with Ende , saying that the film is“very faithful”to the Koran . It is understandable that Ende would not like the movie when it relies on lenient fancy to produce a trivial horse sense of fascination . Ende ’s criticisms intimate that this adaptation is too simplistic to catch the core themes of his novel .
8Anne Rice
Liked: Interview With The Vampire (1994)
Anne Rice ’s primary worry withInterview with the Vampire’smovie adaptation was thecasting of the lamia Lestat . Rice initially agreed with Bible fans who did not cerebrate that Tom Cruise was right for the roleand even want his cobalt - sensation Brad Pitt to play Lestat , rather than the interviewee Louis . She was later on get ahead over by Cruise ’s performance:“I like to believe Tom ’s Lestat will be remembered the way Olivier ’s Hamlet is remember . Others may play the role some day but no one will ever forget Tom ’s translation of it”(viaEsquire ) .
7Stephen King
Liked: The Shawshank Redemption (1994)
UnlikeThe Shining , Stephen King joined moving picture critics in praisingThe Shawshank Redemption . The picture depicts a friendly relationship between two yard bird at the fictional Shawshank Prison and is one of the most lauded movies ever . It is based on King ’s novellaRita Hayworth and the Shawshank Redemption , which does not include several of the motion picture ’s plot point . At the time ofThe Shawshank Redemption’s20th anniversary , King shared ( viaOscars.org ) that"When he first saw [ the movie ] , [ he ] realized that he ’d [ director Frank Darabont]made not just one of the best pic ever done from my work , but a likely movie classic . "
When Darabont was n’t happy with Tim Robbins ' constitution , King ensure him,“people are n’t snuff it to comment the composition , because they ’ll be crying”(viaOscars.org ) . However , King had a strange criticism ofThe Shawshank Redemption’sendingtwist . According toThe Shawshank Redemption’sDVD commentary , King thought that the hole through which Andyescapes Shawshank was too cartoonishly circular . On the other hand , many viewers have wondered how Andy reattached the notice to the wall from inside the tunnel .
6Ursula K. Le Guin
Disliked: Legend of Earthsea (2004)
Ursula K. Le Guin , a pioneering author in the fantasy musical genre , published an essay viaSlatein 2004 critiquing the Sci Fi Channel ’s TV miniseries adaptation of her Earthsea Holy Scripture . Le Guin say :
" I do n’t know what the film is about . It ’s full of scenes from the story , arranged differently , in an entirely unlike plot of ground , so that they make no sense . My friend is Ged , a son with red - brownish skin . In the pic , he ’s a petulant clean kid . [ … ] They then place me several versions of the hand — and told me that shooting had already start . I had been cut out of the process . And just as rapidly , wash , which had been a crucial element , had been cut out of my story . "
Le Guin also says that a major factor in her determination to sell the rights to her leger was Sci Fi ’s assurance thatLord of the Ringsco - author Philippa Boyens would be working on the handwriting . Boyens ended up leaving the project . The adaptation was overall an injustice to Le Guin ’s piece of work . Studio Ghibli also releasedTales from Earthseain 2006 , of which Le Guin was less vital but still disappointed . She told Goro Miyazaki,“It is not my book . It is your moving picture . It is a good movie”(viaursulakleguin.com ) .
5Rick Riordan
Disliked: Percy Jackson & The Olympians: The Lightning Theif (2010) And Percy Jackson: Sea Of Monsters (2013)
Rick Riordan has repeatedly criticized thePercy Jacksonmovies of the 2010s , conduct to his personal liaison in the reboot . Riordan wrote extensively about the moving picture on his website ( viarickriodan.com ) . He says that he had no control over the movies and divvy up his 2009 electronic mail to the producer , in which he utter his business about the role being senesce up and the story overall .
The producers went ahead with their plan , only for Riordan to be proven correct . In his 2018 blog post , Riordan says,“Even if some reboot encounter someday , I would have ZERO control over it . “However , Riordan is credited as a Centennial State - Maker of thePercy JacksonTV show . He expressed optimism about this adjustment , saying ( viaTheWrap),“If you ’re a lover of the books , I believe you’re able to rest easy . I cerebrate you ’re give out to be very pleased . And I guess it holds up very well even if you have n’t learn the Book ! "
4Margot Lee Shetterly
Liked: Hidden Figures (2016)
Margot Lee Shetterly unequivocally said ( viaThe Independent),“I’m so happy with what the filmmakers did . One of the biggest compliment to the book and the flick is that Katherine Johnson and her syndicate were very extremely complimentary . ”Shetterly pen the bookHidden Figures , establish on the life of Katherine Johnsonand the other contraband women who worked as NASA mathematicians during the space race . The movie was nominate for three Oscars : Best Picture , Best Adapted Screenplay , and Best Actress in a Supporting Role .
3Kevin Kwan
Liked: Crazy Rich Asians (2018)
Kevin Kwan was initially offer a movie deal in 2013 for his bookCrazy Rich Asiansif he agreed to let the protagonist Rachel be play by a livid woman ( viaNPR ) . Kwan rejected this andCrazy Rich Asianswent on to be the first major Hollywood moving-picture show with an all - Asiatic cast . Crazy Rich Asians 2is still in development , and there have been no confirmations about the continuation for some meter . Referring to the 2018 movie , Kwan says ( viaBusiness Insider ):
The first prison term I check the pic they did a secret screening just for me , and I was blown away . [ … ] we really , really desire to take our time and get it done right . We knew how important this was becoming so we wanted everything to devolve into property perfectly , from finding the best director , to finding the amazing shape that we ’ve tack together , to filming on location in Singapore and Hong Kong and Malaysia . We await five extra months so that Constance Wu could be in the moving-picture show . "
2Andrzej Sapkowski
Disliked: The Witcher (2019-Present)
Fans of Andrzej Sapkowski ’s books have pick apart Netflix’sThe Witcherfor its change to the rootage material . Sapkowski has tried to address this , but was shut out of the adaptation process:“Maybe , I gave them some idea , but they never listened to me . But it ’s normal”(viaThe Hollywood Reporter ) . While he may not have directly criticized the show in this interview , his attitude towards Netflix is not encouraging . Doing an belief of a Netflix executive , Sapkowski said,“Who ’s this ? It ’s a writer , it ’s nobody . ”Netflix is now headed intoThe Witcherseason 4and is facing challenges including a recast of the independent role and decreased viewership during season 3 .
fancy novels are sly to adapt in Hollywood , though some adaptations tramp so far from the material there ’s no admiration why they did n’t work out .
1George R. R. Martin
Liked: House Of The Dragon (2022-Present)
George R. R. Martin did not knock theGame of Thronesending in a flash but reportedly said ( viaVariety),“By Season 5 and 6 , and certainly 7 and 8 , I was middling much out of the iteration . ”However , Martin has praise theHouse of the Dragonwriters and cast ( viageorgerrmartin.com ):
HOUSE OF THE DRAGON has helped clear up my Sundays as well . I intend , I can not really review the show , that would be unbalanced , I am scarcely objective … but I do want to commend Ryan Condal and Miguel Sapochnik and the dramatis personae and crew for the employment they ’ve done . Sunday ’s installment , “ Lord of the Tides , ” was everything I hoped it should be . praise to Eileen Shim , the scriptwriter , to Geeta Patel , the music director , to our incredible stamp … and in particular to Paddy Considine , for his characterization of King Viserys , the First of His Name . [ … ] Paddy deserves an Emmy for this installment alone .
The mold and crews of all script - to - screen adaptations Bob Hope for this variety of praise , but they are unlikely to get it if they ignore the author ’s vision .
origin : IndieWire , BBC , People , Esquire , Oscars.org , Slate , ursulakleguin.com , rickriodan.com , TheWrap , The Independent , Business Insider , The Hollywood newsman , Variety , georgerrmartin.com
