The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes
Summary
The central secret ofThe Hunger Games : The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakesis whether Lucy Gray Baird survived , but one hypothesis suggests that she live on to be a part of Katniss ' story inThe Hunger Games . Coriolanus Snow himself never knew for sure if he had successfully bolt down his lover in the woods near District 12 , but he see that she was no recollective of importance . If she had return home to the Covey , Lucy Gray likely would have been execute for Mayfair Lipp ’s murder , so she was no harm to Snow either way . Still , if the District 12 testimonial ofThe Ballad of Songbirds and Snakeswaited a few years to return , she might have go unnoticed .
Though there is never a percipient answer regardingthe closing of Lucy Gray ’s story , it ’s potential that she eventually returned to District 12 . It ’s express at the end ofThe Ballad of Songbirds and Snakesthat everyone ultimately forgot about the victor of the 10th Hunger Games , even those of the coal minelaying district . If Lucy Gray had left a girl and returned a woman , it ’s possible no one would have even mark . She could have grow one-time in District 12 , especially given her cognition of hunt and comestible plants . Lucy Gray was a survivor , and as such , she could have helped the younger generation survive as well . Of course , she would have had to exchange her name .
The Hunger Games : The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes ends ambiguously for one major character . We let on down the prequel ’s ending & what ’s next .
Lucy Gray Became Greasy Sae After The Ballad Of Songbirds & Snakes - Theory Explained
Greasy Sae was an old womanhood who was largely bequeath out of theHunger Gamesmovies , but she had a major function from the kickoff to the close of the books . She was oft at the Hob and was experience to be one of Katniss and Gale ’s in effect customers for buy game ( even wild dog , which she called beef once it was in her sweat ) . Though her precise old age is never given , Katniss described her as a bony old woman , and being honest-to-god was a rare occurrent in District 12 . Greasy Sae was clearly a subsister — just like Lucy Gray had been .
At the very least , it seems that Greasy Sae has a connection to the Covey , whose names follow a similar cadence and who are know for their foraging knowledge .
Though there were never any major indicator that these twocharacters were the same inThe Hunger GamesorThe Ballad of Sonbirds and Snakes , this theory progress to a bit of sense . Lucy Gray and Greasy Sae have similar and unequalled name , which feels like a calculated literary pick on source Suzanne Collins ' part . At the very least , it seems that Greasy Sae has a connection to the Covey , whose names stick to a similar cadence and who are known for their scrounge knowledge . Still , there are other indications inThe Hunger Gamesthat the onetime woman is far more crucial than justanymusical nomad .
Greasy Sae Was Inexplicably On President Coin’s Council In District 13
After the firebombs were discharge on District 12 at the ending of theCatching Firebook , Greasy Sae was among those who survived and made it to District 13 . She take on a part as a cook , and , inMockingjay , she was a member of President Coin ’s belittled council . This wound up being to Katniss ' welfare , since Greasy Sae support her request to leave the bunker to hunt plot . The onetime adult female put forward that overbold meat would make her job as a cook far easier , butit seems unknown that Greasy Sae would be a member of Coin ’s inner circlesimply for her noesis of food .
However , if Greasy Sae had once been a Hunger Games victor who knew President Snow intimately , she would have been far more interesting to President Coin . Lucy Gray had n’t been particularly truehearted to District 12 inThe Ballad of Songbirds and Snakessince she deliberate herself among the nomadic Covey , but decades of residence there could have changed this . When Snow bombed 12,this might have been enough for Lucy Gray / Greasy Sae to join the fight against him , which would have meant telling President Coin who she really was .
The intriguing prequel , The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes , adds fuel to a lot of The Hunger Games theories , but it also ruins this cardinal one .
Greasy Sae Volunteered To Care For Katniss After Coin’s Execution In The Hunger Games
AfterKatniss execute President Coin inThe Hunger Games : Mockingjay , she was allowed to render to her home in District 12 . The only region that had subsist the bombing was Victor ’s Village , where Katniss , Peeta , and Haymitch had been let to live after their triumph in the arena . ineffective to care for herself , Greasy Sae maltreat in to front after her . The honest-to-god womanhood take one of the mansions for herself and her survive granddaughter and visited Katniss daily to fix for her .
Greasy Sae had always had a soft spot for Katniss , and this never required much justification . They were both residents of the impoverished Seam who ascertain to subsist on the nation and trade at the Hob and , therefore , shared a profound affinity . Still , Greasy Sae being Lucy Gray would summate a whole new floor of connection between them . The old charwoman would have understood better than anyone what it meant to be a Hunger Games victorwho was thoroughly despised by Coriolanus Snow . So , while it was too atrocious for other house physician of District 12 to give back , it makes sense that Greasy Sae / Lucy Gray would volunteer to go back and care for Katniss . Plus , as a victor , she had a right to last in Victor ’s Village as well .
Though it seems unlikely that Collins ' had conceived of Lucy Gray when she wroteThe Hunger Games , the book bring up that a District 12 Hunger Games victor had been forgotten — she may have always mean this to be Greasy Sae .
There Are Several Problems With The Lucy Gray/Greasy Sae Theory
Of naturally , the theory thatThe Hunger Games ' Greasy Sae wasThe Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes’Lucy Gray has its problems . Since there is n’t much conclusive evidence , it still feel like a stretch . to boot , the entire stage of Lucy Gray ’s story is that , whether she was killed by Snow or supervise to break away , she was free . rejoin to stick out in District 12 seems to contradict the intended symbolisation here . There ’s also the fact thatLucy Gray would be in her eighty bythe events ofThe Hunger Games . Though this is a reasonable age for a Capitol citizen like President Snow , living to such an age in District 12 would be near impossible .
Still , theHunger Gamesbooks typically gave very piddling centering to the residents of District 12 , with many , even Katniss ' parents , never even given names . Those who were sport , like Madge Undersee , had a deeper link to the story of District 12 and the Hunger Games themselves ( Madge ’s aunty had been a tribute alongside Haymitch ) . SinceGreasy Sae was among the only District 12 characters to maintain a predominant role through each of theHunger Gamesbooks , it certainly seems , in a literary good sense , that she was more critical than she seemed . Regardless of whether she isThe Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes ' Lucy Gray , Greasy Sae is an interesting character deserving a second look .
