Related
Summary
WhileChristopher NolanandMartin Scorsesehave some shared history when it comes to the Oscars , the 2024 Academy Awards are likely to make this even more pronounced . Christopher Nolan’sOppenheimerlooks like a potential frontrunner for the Oscar for Best Picture , though Martin Scorsese’sKillers of the Flower Mooncould be an upset . Oppenheimerwas a smash impinge on at the box office , whereasKillers of the Flower Moonunderperformed given its large budget , but Scorsese ’s film earned widespread acclamation for its trio of star central performance from Leonardo DiCaprio , Robert De Niro , and Lily Gladstone .
Until 2007 , the Oscars had historically been shockingly unkind to the senior of these two filmmakers . Scorsese was put up for the Best Director Oscar many times , but it was n’t until four 10 after his movie debut that he win the awarding . This was forThe Departed , which was also his first film to win Best Picture . The following year , the success ofThe Dark Knightelevated Nolan from an emerge blockbuster filmmaker to a potential awards candidate . Another 10 and a one-half afterward , Nolan is still waiting for an Oscar win after nominations for Best Director , Best Picture , and Best Original Screenplay .
Christopher Nolan & Martin Scorsese Have Never Competed Against Each Other For The Oscars
Even when Nolan and Scorsese’s Oscar hopefuls arrived in the same year, they didn’t match categories.
Before 2023 , only two other years saw the discharge of both Martin Scorsese and Christopher Nolan moving picture . In 2006 , Scorsese hadThe Departedand Nolan hadThe Prestige . The former received five Oscar nominations while the latter earned two , yet none of these overlap in the same category , asThe Departedwasn’t recognized for its cinematography or art management , whereas Nolan ’s motion picture was .
The other class before 2023 that saw the handout of Scorsese and Nolan film was 2010 . This fourth dimension , Scorsese’sShutter Islandwasn’t an Oscar campaigner at all , while Nolan’sInceptionwas . Interestingly , both were Leonardo DiCaprio vehicle that saw the actor pass most of the moving picture inside his mind , butShutter Islandproved too pulpy for the Oscars .
Even though the two film maker have never rifle head - to - head teacher in the raceway for Best Director or Best Picture before , Nolan and Scorsese have issue the same issue of movies in the intervening 13 years . Nolan has train five movies since 2010 , start out withThe Dark Knight Risesand ending withOppenheimer . Meanwhile , Scorsese has also made five movies during the same time , starting with 2011’sHugoand ending withKillers of the Flower Moon .
Many of these movies have net the twosome Best Director nominations in their several years , but neither Nolan nor Scorsese has win during this sentence . As such , the battle between Nolan and Scorsese for Best Director in 2024 will be severely - fought . Although this would be Scorsese ’s second achiever , this would amount to only two of his 26 movies winning . In contrast , Nolan earning an Oscar for Best Director would be his first winnings in 12 movies .
The official Oscars 2024 nominating address have been announced , including the 10 Best Picture campaigner , and here ’s a prediction of who will make headway .
Martin Scorsese Only Has One More Best Picture Nomination Than Christopher Nolan Since The Departed
Scorsese earned three Best Picture nominations while Nolan racked up two.
Three Martin Scorsese movies were nominated for Best Picture afterThe Departed ’s profits in 2007 : Hugoin 2012,TheWolf of Wall Streetin 2014 , andThe Irishmanin 2020 . Nolan ’s two movies nominated for Best Picture during that same meter wereInceptionin 2010 andDunkirkin 2018 . This meansScorsese currently has one more Best Picture nomination than his young competitorduring the same frame of time .
However , this may not intend much when it comes to their chances of winning . After all , the preceding decades see Scorsese movies rack up another five fruitless nomination for Best Picture beforeThe Departed ’s profits : Taxi Driverin 1977,Raging Bullin 1981,Goodfellasin 1991,Gangs of New Yorkin 2003 , andThe Aviatorin 2005 . It ’s worth mark that Scorsese was only in person constitute in the Best Picture family withHugo , The Wolf of Wall Street , andThe Irishman , as these are the only three out of the nine total nominees for the prize that he produced . He also producedKillers of the Flower Moon .
Scorsese Has Two More Best Director Nominations Than Nolan Since 2007
The older director has three nominations, but Nolan earned only one.
When it comes to Best Director nominations at the Oscars , the playing field is not quite as close . After his win forThe Departed , Martin Scorsese was constitute for Best Director for the same three movies of his that were nominate for Best Picture : Hugo , The Wolf of Wall Street , andThe Irishman . Nolan only got a single nomination in the category , forDunkirk .
WhileNolan is more overdue for an Oscar , Scorsese can still boast more entire Best Director nomination with nine . The titles almost check his moving-picture show nominated for Best Picture , with one exception . He was n’t name forTaxi Driver ; he was nominated , however , forThe Last Temptation of Christin 1989 . Out of all of those opportunities , he only won the award once , forThe Departed .
Martin Scorsese & Christopher Nolan Both Have Strong Cases To Win The 2024 Best Director Oscar
Killers of the Flower MoonandOppenheimerare very likely nominees in the category.
Killers of the Flower Moonhas a good snap at winning Best Picture , Best Director , or both at the 2024 Oscars . This would be Scorsese ’s moment of his vocation , but his first in 17 age . Meanwhile , a win forOppenheimerwould be Nolan ’s firstin either category . Therefore , both could reasonably be see as redemption profits for the Academy not recognizing the pair earlier and , in the case of Scorsese , more often . However , this kind of " due " win has become more and more uncommon at the Oscars in late years . FromCODAtoParasitetoEverything Everywhere All at Once , the Academy does n’t view and prize career longevity so much any longer .
Oppenheimer Vs. Killers Of The Flower Moon: Which Movie Has A Better Chance Of Winning Best Picture
Oppenheimer’s box office success could give it an edge over Scorsese’s flop.
Christopher Nolan’sOppenheimerseems to be the stronger contender for the Oscar for Best Picture , as the movie proved a huge success at the box office staff . Oppenheimergrossed almost $ 1 billiondespite its three - time of day runtime , an achievement thatKillers of the Flower Mooncouldn’t hope to repeat . In contrast , the much more expensive Martin Scorsese movie realise only $ 154.4 million on a budget of $ 200 million . While the 206 - second moving-picture show was never expect to be a blockbuster , Scorsese ’s proportional box office failure may hurtKillers of the Flower Moon ’s Best Picture prospectsbecause both movies earned equally widespread vital acclaim .
That tell , Oppenheimerwill have struggles of its own . Nolan ’s motion-picture show was famously criticize for conk out to limn the impact of J. Robert Oppenheimer ’s infamous invention in Hiroshima and Nagasaki . The thorny ethical question of whetherOppenheimershould have depicted the bombingsis divisive , and this kind of discourse may smart its Best Picture prospects . Of course , if the Oscars want to avoid controversial picks , they would need to steer clean of Scorsese ’s movie , too . Killers of the Flower Moon ’s storey focus on the murder of Native Americans by powerfulness - hungry sociopaths and , while its post - compound critique of capitalist greed is applaudable , the film ’s brutal furiousness receive criticism .
Oppenheimer is already expect to be a heavy hitter at the Oscars , but a specific win for Christopher Nolan could facilitate fix a 15 - year - honest-to-god cut .
Killers Of The Flower Moon & Oppenheimer Share The Same Best Picture Problem
Neither Nolan nor Scorsese could be called an underdog despite their struggles.
The biggest obstacles blocking bothKillers of the Flower MoonandOppenheimerfrom earning either Best Picture or Best Director are their filmmakers , their budget , and their high profiles . The Oscar have shone a light on less - picture film in recent year . In 2023 , the Academy highlighted an effort from a smaller studio withEverything Everywhere All at Once ’s profits for Best Picture . In 2022,CODAwas a surprise winner given its depressed visibility . In 2019,Parasite ’s achiever saw the movie become the first non - English - language picture to win Best Picture . Within this context , it is arduous to argue that Nolan and Scorsese constitute outsiders or underdog .
Whether it’sOppenheimer ’s $ 100 million price tag or the $ 200 million budget ofKillers of the Flower Moon , both movies run big as their directors were ambitious with protracted project . Both movies are stuffed with megastars and , althoughOppenheimerfeatures more renowned faces , Killers of the Flower Moontapped two of movie house ’s biggest live actors . As such , no reviewer could call either movie a surprise winner or an upset , and this is the quality that the Oscars have recently been prioritize . WhileChristopher Nolanmight win at the Oscars andMartin Scorseseis a little less potential to earn his second figurine , both directors may leave the 2024 Oscars let down .
