Related
Summary
Albus Dumbledore was very lovesome of the Chocolate Frog cards in his honor , and aHarry Pottertheory would excuse why . Though they never play a major part in Harry ’s taradiddle , Chocolate Frog cards often moderate useful chip of entropy about famous witches and maven . The magically revivify amphibious goody always came with a single card , and young phallus of the wizarding world usually pull in these and trade them like American baseball game cards . It seemed inHarry Potterthat the least rare of these menu was the one dedicated to the Hogwarts master himself , and Dumbledore may have taken reward of this to serve his own determination .
The first time Harry opens a Chocolate Frog , he get a board with Albus Dumbledore ’s image on it . ThroughouttheHarry Potterseries , the Boy Who Lived pick up several other famous witches ' and thaumaturgist ' cards , and , finally , he , Ron , and Hermione all got Chocolate Frog cards celebrate their great deed of conveyance . This honor was a kind of proof of celebrity reserved for the most noteworthy figures of the wizarding world , preceding and present . Though Dumbledore had receive much more esteemed honors , he jest that he cared the most about his Chocolate Frog card , andaReddittheoryprovides an excellent cause why .
It ’s been over a decade since the Harry Potter movie serial enwrap up with Deathly Hallows Part 2 - what are the cast members doing now ?
Dumbledore Used His Chocolate Frog Cards As Informants - Theory Explained
Albus Dumbledore had the baffling power to acknowledge what was hold out on nearly everywhere in the wizarding world . He acknowledge whatever mischief Harry was getting up to , he understood Ron and Hermione ’s personality ( despite never having expend much meter with them ) , and he had a firm idea of the various goings on at the Ministry of Magic as well . InHarry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets , Dumbledore knew to send Harry ’s school letter to the Weasleys , with Arthur even tell " Does n’t miss a trick , that gentleman’s gentleman . " Aside from Divination ( a open Dumbledore scorn ) , it seems the only way he could know this is through some rather sneaky informants .
A theory on Reddit suggests thatDumbledore took advantage of his Chocolate Frog cards to playact as his source . Since this wizarding humanity treat was so pop , and Dumbledore was among the more common card a person could get , this could make some sense . Dumbledore often took vantage ofthe headmaster portraits in his power at Hogwartsto send messages and even snoop at other positioning , so it suffer to reasonableness that he could do the same with his Chocolate Frog counterpart . It would likely involve a routine of magical tampering , but as canny as Dumbledore was , this would surely have been within his abilities .
Dumbledore Feared Losing His Dedicated Chocolate Frog Cards In Order Of the Phoenix
InHarry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix , Dumbledore was dismantle of many honors the wizarding world had contribute on him . When it was mentioned that he had been remove from the Wizengamot , he stated that the intervention from the Ministry of Magic did n’t nettle him a fleck , so long as he was n’t removed from the Chocolate Frog cards . Of of course , this simply seemed like one of Dumbledore ’s quirky way of subside the tenseness . However , if thisHarry Pottertheory is true , then it could be that the headmaster was being lightheartedly true .
At a prison term when he had lost a undecomposed mountain of his influence in the wizarding world , Dumbledore ’s Chocolate Frog cards might have been the best way for him to stay informedabout what was materialize in the wizarding world . Suppose the Minister for Magic himself had one of the Dumbledore card tucked aside in his desk . In that case , the headmaster might have been able to get a few tidbits report back to him about how the wizarding authorities was handling ( or not handle ) the Dark Lord ’s return . Therefore , it make sense that of all his laurels , the Chocolate Frog cards would have been the honour Dumbledore would least like to lose .
Ron’s Philosopher’s Stone Line Supports The Chocolate Frog Theory
Of naturally , the semantics of how Dumbledore would expend Chocolate Frog cards is a slight more complicated . The theory reckon on the idea that the images on these collectible can journey between the cards spread throughout the wizarding world . Of naturally , Ron ’s line to Harry the first sentence they fulfil onthe Hogwarts Express inHarry Potterimplies that this is precisely the case . When Dumbledore ’s range of a function disappeared from Harry ’s posting , Ron say , " Well , you ca n’t await him to string up around all day , can you ? " This betoken a single , or at most a select few , flyspeck Dumbledore figures that must hop around from card to card .
InHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows , it is give away that the guinea pig of a portrait can go to other portraits of themselves , even if they are miles away . This is why ( in the al-Qur’an ) Harry , Ron , and Hermione stole Phineas Nigellus Black ’s portrait from Grimmauld Place . Since the honest-to-goodness Slytherin master had a portrayal in the headmaster ’s office at Hogwarts , they hoped Professor Black could give them information about what Snape had been up to . Inversely , Snape used the same portrayal to snoop on Harry . If all this was possible , and Chocolate Frog cards operate the same agency , then thisHarry Pottertheory could be perfectly viable .
Phineas Nigellus Black ’s portraiture was how Snape knew where to go away the Sword of Gryffindor in the Deathly Hallows al-Qur’an .
The Dumbledore Chocolate Frog Theory Has Some Problems
Like any hypothesis , the " Dumbledore ’s Chocolate Frog cards are spies " hypothesis has some problems . First , if Chocolate Frog poster worked the same way as other magical portrayal , it ’s surprising that no one would have become funny of them before . It would be awfully risky to partake in in the chocolaty treat if a sorcerer had some secrets to keep . It ’s possible that the company that produces the Chocolate Frogs look at some security measures to reassure customer that the card could n’t get up to mischief . Perhaps , unlike headmaster portraits , the figures on the cards were only smart enough to move but not to communicate more than a couple of basic musical phrase — but Dumbledore ’s magic could have changed this .
This bring up the next trouble with this theory — it count on Dumbledore being extremely unethical . It would be a monolithic breach of secrecy to manipulate his Chocolate Frog card to report back to him , even by Dumbledore ’s standard . It ’s especially problematical weigh the mass who would be the most likely to collect Chocolate Frog cards would be tiddler , and parents finding out their son or girl ’s professor was spot on them through their miniature would be quite the cataclysm . Of course , Albus Dumbledore tended to make for fast and loose with the estimate of ethics , so perhaps thisHarry Pottertheory falls right within his character .
