Related
Summary
The Golden Trio spent a portion of fourth dimension trying to figure out a fashion to demolish Horcruxes inHarry Potter , but one theory paint a picture there was a possible solvent they never thought of . address Voldemort ’s store - away soul fragment was a significant point of frustration , especially since Dumbledore never ascertain fit to recite Harry how they could be destruct . gratefully , Hermione ’s skill at inquiry allowed her to figure out out a solution , but it only intend more jump through hoops . However , there was a magical artefact that Harry and his ally had been bring out to age before that could have been a commodious option inHarry ceramist .
InHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows , Harry , Ron , and Hermione successfully obtained Slytherin ’s locket , which Voldemort had turn into one of his six intentional Horcruxes . Unfortuantely , they had no means to demolish it , which became a point of serious contention in their journey . Hermione had discovered a distich of known , passing dangerous method — basilisk spitefulness and Fiendfyre . The Sword of Gryffindor had absorbed the former , which was how they eventually grapple to destroy Slytherin ’s locket . However , since Harry did n’t have this weapon until much later , another option would have been helpful .
The Veil In The Department Of Mysteries Could Have Destroyed A Horcrux
A theory suggest that the mysterious Veil — the one Sirius Black fall through inHarry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix — could have destroyed a Hocrux . lay in in the Department of Mysteries at the Ministry of Magic , the Veil attend to as an archway to expiry . When Sirius went through it , he passed on to the hereafter , unable to return or to be keep an eye on . Since a Horcrux is like a body in that it is a vessel for a soulfulness , it remain firm to ground that tossing a Horcrux through it would see the soul within enter the afterlife .
Of naturally , the fragments stored within a Horcrux are n’t whole , so how they interact with the Veil could be different . Still , it ’s of import to remember how Horcruxes work to get down with . When a adept has a Horcrux hidden away is kill , their soul can not " move on " since a small-arm of that soul still survive in the world of the living . The Horcrux serve as a leash to that humans . However , sincewhatever is on the other side of the Veil isnotin the Earth of the living , a Horcrux that passes through would no longer be able to tether its master to life . Therefore , even if the Horcrux vas were n’t technically demolish , it would still , in hypothesis , be rendered useless .
The Golden Trio Had To Break Into The Ministry Of Magic Anyway (But It Would Have Been Tricky)
Harry , Ron , and Hermione already plan to break into the Ministry of Magic , so they could have potentially headed to the Department of Mysteries after retrieving Slytherin ’s locket from Dolores Umbridge . For this to work , Harry would have had to keep his temper under control condition , but if he had live that his mission at the Ministry was n’t over yet , he might have managed to keep things together a little longer . Still , maintaining restraint was never Harry ’s persuasiveness — and that ’s only the beginning of the difficulties that would have look the Golden Trio had they decided to head for the Veil .
It ’s possible that after the events atthe Ministry of Magic inHarry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix , the Veil was move out of the Department of Mysteries . Or , the Ministry might have realized it needed increased security after a group of teenagers detect their mode in . to boot , though the Veil could theoretically incapacitate Slytherin ’s locket , there would be no way to prove that this method was successful without getting rid of the other Horcruxes , killing Voldemort , and see what materialise . If Voldemort ’s primal person persist tethered to the world of the keep , there might not have been a way to get Slytherin ’s locket back from the Veil . Therefore , while interesting , this possibility might not have been the good option .
How Did The Veil Really Work In Harry Potter?
The Department of Mysteries was a meet place for the Veil inHarry Pottersince the item of how it worked were never fully explain . All we know is that when Sirius passed through it , there was no bring in him back . Harry usedthe Resurrection Stone to temporarily get his godfather back inHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows , however , so it ’s evident that Sirius cease up in the same office as Lily and James , who never had any fundamental interaction with the Veil .
When Harry draw end the Veil inHarry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix , he listen voice coming from the other side , something that , of the chemical group , only Luna could hear as well . Since it was revealed earlier that Harry and Luna could see Thestrals , it ’s simulate that the pair could learn those beyond the Veil because of their intimate familiarity with death — they were hear the voices of their asleep loved one . This further proves that the Veil inHarry Potterleads forthwith to the Great Beyond , where disconnected souls , like Horcruxes and Lord Voldemort , can not hold up .
