The Boys
Summary
OneThe Boystheory indicatingGen fin ’s Sam is the new Black Noir is a more shocking reveal than a Homelander clone . Gen V ’s season 1 endingshook upThe Boys’universe and look to make Homelander even more powerful , especially as Sam apparently joined him . Sam was one of the strongest characters introduced inGen Vand , despite his family relationship with Emma and his comparatively good nature , he participated in the supe rising . The show create a watershed between supes and humans , making Sam ’s involvement exceedingly dangerous . Gen Vhighlighted that Sam could often lose mastery , killing numerous people throughout the show , and now , he could conjoin the Seven .
The Boysappear to have a new Black Noir , prompting theories to come forth after the character was stamp out in time of year 3 . The suggestion that Sam could have taken the role might seem far - fetched , but there are several grounds why it act . The Boysseason 4 trailerdidn’t show anyGen Vcharacters , make their absence unusual consider the two shows are presuppose to be yoke . It seems likely the dawdler intentionally shroud them to keep people guessing , but perhaps Sam was there all along . If Sam is the new Black Noir , it would be an even grownup reveal than imitate Noir ’s laughable stock .
Gen V’s Sam’s Similarities To The Boys' Black Noir
Despite get very different backgrounds , Sam and Black Noir share several similarities . Both characters often experience round-eyed hallucinations . InGen V , Sam oftentimes found himself lecture to the tool he hallucinated , who had a heavy influence over him . Whether they were criticizing him or manipulating him into decisions , they were a constant quantity in his lifetime . Sam even expire on a killing fling inGen V , imagine real people as puppets , perhaps to make killing them easier in his mind . Black Noir also hallucinated cartoon character that talked with him . Unlike Sam , Noir ’s hallucinations were more supportive and acted as comforting friend to help him through his harm .
Each theatrical role also faced their own past trauma , withBlack Noir being one ofThe Boys ' most tragical supes . The grounds he ca n’t talk is due to how badly Soldier Boy wound him when they were teammates alongside the events of Operation Charly , leave lasting impairment both physically and mentally . Sam was also locked up in The Forest for a large part of his life , being subject to almost complete isolation as Godolkin University retrieve him too serious . Even though both characters have saturnine backgrounds , they have still become extremely powerful . Both reference own superhuman durability and frightening fighting skill , although it does n’t come out that was enough to save Black Noir from Homelander .
The Boysseason 4 will premiere on Amazon Prime Video in 2024 .
Why Vought Might Make Sam The New Black Noir
Vought International could make Sam the new Black Noir as they greet how valuable he could be to them . The very same understanding Godolkin mesh Sam up is why Vought might see value in him . Not only is Sam incredibly knock-down and grave , but he is also easily impressionable . Sam put his combine in Emma and became fantastically fond of her since she was the first soul who had exhibit him give care in a foresighted time . Once he left The Forest though , Sam became influenced by those around him , eventually joining Cate to start a supe uprising as they felt superior to humans .
This makes Sam the everlasting new Black Noir for Vought . They could manipulate him into believe that taking on the purpose is for the greater goodness . He has already indicate he is willing to crusade other supes who oppose him , and withGen V ’s Marie Moreau potentially being stronger than Homelander , Vought can use all the help they can get . This reveal would add a sweet young direction to Black Noir and beat the comical twist . The Homelander clone concept being introduced now would find out of placeand having Sam become the new version would be a plausible surprisal that has a more personal link with the overall tale .
The Problem With Sam Being The New Black Noir
While Sam being the newBlack Noir would spice upThe Boysseason 4 ’s story , it does make an obvious problem . With Sam already being an established graphic symbol and a Guardian of Godolkin , making him the new Black Noir would waste his potential . From a story point of survey , putting him into this more inscrutable role would be slimly disappointing , consider the hearing already has a cause to care about him , whether he is liked or not . It could be interesting to see Sam have to be a silent hero in public while sustain a personality outside the costume , but it ’s not the good path to utilize him .
From Vought ’s perspective , it also make more signified to cash in on his Guardian of Godolkin status . He is now seen as a Cuban sandwich by those who still trust Vought , and it would make sense to commercialize him as a burnished untested Hero of Alexandria as opposed to hiding him behind the Black Noir costume . Vought could use Sam as their newfangled herowhile having someone else portray Black Noir , as they would only need him for merchandising reasons , letting Sam become the unfeigned replacement . There are still waysThe Boyscould make Sam as Black Noir work , but it would n’t be the serial publication ' most logical move .
Did The Boys Already Debunk Sam Being The New Black Noir?
Although the Sam hypothesis holds some weight , The Boysmay have already debunk the idea that he is the new Black Noir . The Boyshave already confirm that the worker who played Black Noir in the case will be returning . Nathan Mitchell has played Black Noir for the first three season ; however , Fritzy - Klevans Destine play the character in the time of year 3 flashback , propose that is what the original version looked like . WithBlack Noir alive again inThe Boysseason 4 , there is a chance Mitchell will be the new face of the character , despite having already play him under the suit .
Mitchell ’s return does n’t confirm he ’ll be given this part , but it does make Sam becoming Noir less likely . If Mitchell is still playing him , it would waste Asa Germann ’s involvement by only define him to conniption outside the costume . or else , having Mitchell be Noir and Germann remain as Sam is the good manner to capitalize on having both actors on plank . There are still so many directionsThe Boysseason 4 could go with Black Noir ’s grapheme . As fun as Sam exact the mantle would be , it feels like the dealership ’s best option is to go in a raw instruction , out from Sam and the mirthful origin .
