Related
Summary
Galadriel overcame the enticement to claim the One anchor ring from Frodo inThe Lord of the Rings , but what might have happened if she had n’t ? By its nature , the One Ring made all those it came in contact with desire to maintain its world power , make Frodo ’s journeying to destroy it all the more complicated . in the end , the Hobbits were the most tolerant to its top executive , and though Men were the most susceptible , Elves were far from immune . This is seen during the scene at Lothlórien inThe Lord of the Rings : The Fellowship of the Ringwhen Frodo offered the One Ring to Galadriel , and it took all her military posture to decline .
As seeninThe Lord of The Rings : The Rings of Power , Galadriel is one of the oldest Elves in Middle - earth , having been born in Valinor thousands of years before the start ofThe Lord of the Rings . Even before she became the lady of Lothlórien , she was cognize as among the most brawny in in-between - earth . When she obtained one of the Three Elven Rings of Power , Nenya , she advance more power still . It was potential thanks to Nenya that Galadriel was able to dissent the Ring ’s temptationsince its power is perseverance , protective cover , and concealment from wickedness . Still , had Galadriel failed her " examination " and claimed the One Ring as her own inThe Lord of the Rings , it ’s interesting to consider what might have happened .
The One Ring Would Make Galadriel Incredibly Powerful
When Frodo offer Galadriel Sauron ’s One Ring , she dived into a monologue explaining what she believed — or hoped — would encounter if she accepted it . She said , " In place of the Dark Lord , you will set up a poove , " go on to delineate the version of herself that possess the One Ring as not dark but " beautiful and terrible as the Morning and the Night . " Of course , as her spoken language continued , she segued into the line,“All shall love me and despair!“Ultimately , this perfectly tote up up what would have happened . Galadriel would have intended to do great good with the One Ring , but the desire to be adore would have turned her into a powerful malefic force .
Still , theOne Ring has the power inLord of the Ringsto make its victims believe that they could hold out against such evil , and Galadriel seemed to momently think that she could as well . She said to Frodo , " And now at last it comes . You will give me the Ring freely ! " Since the torture of the Ring begin with the crimes invest to obtain it ( i.e. , Smeagol murdering Deagol and Bilbo cuckold Gollum ) , Frodo willingly handing over the Ring could , in her thinker , have exempted Galadriel from being misdirect . This was , of grade , foolishness , and Galadriel knew it . Though she had obviously considered its power unnumberable prison term before , Galadriel understood that the One Ring would turn her into an evil fairy .
Not Even The One Ring Could Make Galadriel As Powerful As Sauron
Galadriel would have become a abominable military unit inThe Lord of the Ringshad she claim the One Ring , and perhaps her dream of replace Sauron as ruler would have fall true for a moment . However , made from Sauron ’s own iniquity will , no one ( aside from maybe Gandalf ) could have handle the Ring as the Dark Lord could . The weapon would do whatever it could to get back to its master , and in the hands of Galadriel , this process would have only been expedite .
If Galadriel hoped to be the queen of Middle - earth , she would have needed to get rid of her predecessor once and for all . Sauron ’s goal inThe Lord of the Ringswas likely to bring back the Dark Lord Morgoth , and this is something Galadriel could never allow for . She would have call for the One Ring at once to Sauron , contrive to ruin him with it . However , as a Maia , a being far more knock-down than even an Elf like Galadriel , she would have been no couple . The One Ring would have turned on her , Sauron would have claimed it , and Middle - ground would have been lost .
Tolkien said in his letters that Gandalf would have been the only one able-bodied to replace Sauron as Dark Lord .
Why Galadriel Couldn’t Carry The One Ring In LOTR
It was well-defined fromThe Lord of the Ringsthat , had Galadriel taken the One Ring from Frodo , she would have tried to maintain it . However , since she contend to fight away this temptation , she might have been able to at least bear the affair to Mordor to be destroy . As the bearer of Nenya , Galadriel might have even been able to effectively hold back the One Ring from Sauron . However , it ’s also possible that these two Rings would be altogether incompatible ( one being a force against evil and the other made from wickedness ) . Therefore , Galadriel might have needed to choose one or the other .
Therefore , especially if Galadriel had to pass Nenya to another , carrying the One Ring would have head to Galadriel ’s corruption . She was far too ambitious and far too powerful to continue to quash temptation forever . Hobbits , on the other mitt , were far less challenging and power - seeking than the other beings of Middle - worldly concern , which is whyFrodo was perfect for destroying the One Ring inThe Lord of the Rings . Galadriel ’s design surely would have been serious , but it was never her destiny to deal with Sauron ’s horrible arm herself .
